Toward Pluralism: DA Rosen Must Retract His Whistleblower Complaint
June 24, 2020
.jpg)
Last week, Santa Clara County District Attorney Jeffrey Rosen made it clear to his staff that he was prepared to file a whistleblower complaint against Sajid Khan, a deputy alternate public defender in Santa Clara. District Attorney Rosen took exception with a series of blog posts in which Khan criticized DA’s offices around the country for biased practices which abdicate their responsibility to serve the public as arbiters of justice.
District Attorney Rosen erroneously claimed that Khan was hoping to “incite anger and destruction toward us” and had effectively “endangered the safety of everyone” at the office. He hopes that his whistleblower complaint would launch an investigation into Khan. This is a gross overreach on District Attorney Rosen’s part, one which is predicated on the dubious assumption of ill-intent on the part of Khan.
It is clear from Khan’s writings that he speaks from the vantage point of a concerned citizen — not from a place of malice.
In his op-ed, Khan articulated such truisms as “[when] we yell out ‘black lives matter,’ we call for and demand the recognition and valuing of the humanity of black people in this country,” and “don’t forget to make it loud and clear to our DA that black lives matter.” Khan did in fact highlight what he considered gross abrogations of justice on the part of DA’s offices around the country, which included “using illegally collected evidence in their prosecutions,” “prosecuting the very black victims of police violence on trumped-up crimes,” “stripping [black people] of their names, calling them defendants, bodies, criminals, thugs, reducing them to their rap sheets and charges,” and to not living up to the claim that black lives matter.
At no point did District Attorney Rosen contend with Khan’s claims, nor did he address Khan’s clearly well-meaning call for citizens to get engaged in local electoral politics. District Attorney Rosen's inflammatory response was retaliatory. It betrays a District Attorney's office that is more focused on suppressing criticism than engaging with the public they are supposed to serve.
The Muslim Public Affairs Council is committed to ensuring a pluralistic society. We know that a pluralistic society cannot exist where constructive criticism is effectively outlawed. If Sajid Khan, a deputy public defender himself, cannot offer constructive criticism, then where does that leave the broader public?
We call on District Attorney Rosen to issue a public apology to Mr. Khan and retract any formal complaints he may have initiated.
IN THIS SECTION
- Policy Analysis
- Statements & Press
- White House Nominates Rashad Hussain as Ambassador for Religious Freedom
- The Blackhouse Foundation and MPAC’s Hollywood Bureau held their first-ever Television Screenwriting Lab for Black Muslim Writers.
- MPAC CONGRATULATES NUSRAT JAHAN CHOUDHURY ON HISTORIC NOMINATION
- GOP Blocks Coronavirus Bill
- Protect Rights During COVID-19
- Coronavirus Joint Statement
- Senate Passes Coronavirus Relief
- Iran Sanctions In COVID-19
- Historic Senate Relief Package
- Coronavirus Stimulus Problems
- Trump Immigration Suspension is Nothing but Cynical Opportunism
- House Introduces the HEROES Act
- Joint Action to Condemn the Murder of George Floyd
- Toward Pluralism: DA Rosen Must Retract His Whistleblower Complaint
- Supporting of Attorney General Keith Ellison Leading Prosecution for Murder of George Floyd
- Trump’s Executive Order on Census Is Unconstitutional
- MPAC Stands with the NBA Players
- What Muslims Want Heading into the 2020 General Election
- Declare Rittenhouse a Terrorist
- MPAC Firmly Denounces the Failure of the Criminal Justice System for Breonna Taylor
- There Is No Place For Violence in Civil Society
- Updates
- A Win Against White Supremacy
- Mosque Safety & Security
- How We’re Confronting White Supremacy
- Our Work on the Muslim Ban
- 2020 Muslim Voter Guide
- Responding to Covid-19
- Census 2020: What You Need To Know
- Human Security During COVID-19: Our Right
- Quarantine Webinars
- Make an impact in 1, 2, 3...
- Mark Kevin Lloyd is Unfit to Serve in State Department
- SoCal Muslims Show Gratitude To Frontline Workers
- DREAMERS are here to stay!
- A Ramadan Like No Other
- Creating inclusive content for kids & families
- National Muslim Task Force Recommendations for Ramadan During This Pandemic
- Ramadan Mubarak!
- Tale of Two Futures: American Muslim Life After the Election
RELATED STORIES
RELATED MULTIMEDIA
-
2012 Convention Videos
January 7, 2013 -
Al-Marayati interviewed on Viewpoint on Hate Speech
July 29, 2011 -
MPAC Convention Promotional Video
December 6, 2010 -
Dr. Maher Hathout on Elections
October 19, 2010
one-time or monthly donation.